| | President George H.W. Bush at a campaign stop in Stevens Point, Wis., in 1992. Gregory Humphrey, a listener, was there. Diana Walker, via The LIFE Images Collection, via Getty Images | | | Michael Barbaro | | So, about those political rallies. Two weeks ago, we asked for your memories of attending them. Why did you go? What was the experience like? What moments stayed with you? | | Dozens of you wrote in. You recalled the smallest details — the four songs that seemed to play from the loudspeakers on an endless loop, the weight of a parent's hand, the pattern of clothing worn by a candidate's spouse. You recounted the camaraderie of like-minded strangers in a crowd, suddenly drawn together in common cause. And you remembered the exhilaration of witnessing a small slice of history. | | In 1992, listener Gregory Humphrey attended a rally in Stevens Point, Wis., for George H.W. Bush, who had been campaigning with a copy of David McCullough's biography of Harry Truman in hand. Bush arrived by train, just as Truman had when he was campaigning in the state. "This was a moment that made time seem to move backwards as the loud engine and sharp whistle brought a president to that little depot," Humphrey wrote us. | | That same year, Catherine Sanderson attended a rally for Bush's opponent, Bill Clinton, in Georgia. She remembers a perhaps less grand moment: A speaker tried thanking the popular band playing on stage, but butchered its name, "saying R.E.M. as one word, instead of (correctly) saying each letter, R-E-M." | | You marveled at the candidates' endurance and discipline, wondering how they could deliver so many speeches to so many people. For a college political science class, Daniel Groce visited rallies for John McCain and Mike Huckabee. "I find it impressive that not only are they able to stay on message," he wrote, "but also they can still make you feel like you're hearing something for the first time that they've said a thousand times." | | But Patrick Stanton found himself acutely aware that the political rally he attended, for Barack Obama in 2008, was a performance — and he was unsure who, exactly, was the intended audience. "Political rallies aren't for the people in the audience or really for the average person, but for the people watching it on TV," he wrote. "They are for sound bites and news clips." | | A few of you recalled the kindness of strangers and the warmth of political kinship. Steve Stern was at a rally for Bernie Sanders in 2015, struggling to see over a tall man in front of him. "When he saw this, he very politely offered to change places with me so that I could take pictures," he wrote. "And while Bernie's message resonated with me back then, my lasting impression was that of the courtesy of the throngs of people there." | | Isa Chancey had a different reaction after attending rallies for Sanders, Clinton and the Democratic Party in California. They had all been political echo chambers. She admired the speakers, but one after another, they affirmed the same points of view, unchallenged. "That is why I end up feeling uncomfortable at events and rallies like that," she wrote. | | But on this, there was universal agreement: Nobody regretted attending a political rally, and everybody remembered it vividly. | | Talk to Michael on Twitter: @mikiebarb. | | |
沒有留言:
張貼留言